Talk:Boo/@comment-28952308-20160801120512/@comment-16533050-20160801194033

You are correct stating that it would indeed make more sense for the chap down on the street below to be Boo. However, nothing you have indicated in your post is actual evidence of him being so.

As the guy who made the original article, I too had thought had thought the thug guarding the steps was Boo and prepared the article accordingly. However, I am a stickler for details and replay certain scenes over and over for new clues and to get the best possible descriptions for the articles I add. During the course of my research, I could find nothing that actually indicates that Boo is the man missing from the conversation.

Everything you suggested or pointed out as 'evidence' is in fact speculation. Whether or not it makes sense, the fact remains that the speaker indicates the man behind him when saying 'Boo' and not the other Bottle Street thug.

In fact, the guy at the bottom of the stairs, despite standing guard and supposedly being alert for signs of trouble, almost never seems to come up to help the others when the fight breaks out amongst the three thugs above him. Therefore I doubt he would earn his 5 coins. :P