Talk:Black Shard Arm/@comment-44309297-20200606090754/@comment-16533050-20200607040116

This is just my opinion, but I feel the arm would only work properly for Billie Lurk.

Until Billie meets up with Woodrow, the Eye has gone quiet and she is unable to summon the Twin-Bladed knife. And this was while Billie already had them attached.

Maybe through a ritual similar to what Woodrow performed, someone else could get the arm to work for them, but it still seems unlikely for a new person to get them to work. The bits of the arm weren't always really connected and some pieces just 'floated' there; so would the magic still exist after removed from her.

And even then would the powers be the same? The Outsider handed out the same Mark to every one, but their powers varied with each individual. Would the arm do the same?

Also, it seems the Eye is necessary for the Arm to work properly, so both would be needed. A lot of 'ifs' and guesswork. :/