Talk:Meagan Foster/@comment-43614028-20200810035332/@comment-16533050-20200810052612

Stilton witnessed the ritual which sent him into madness. Foster grew worried and made her way to the manor to investigate. The Grand Guard caught her and a fight ensued during which she was badly injured resulting in the loss of her eye and arm.

It doesn't say specifics, so, she either lost them immediately and escaped and or both were injured to the point of needing to be removed after the fact.

With Stilton not attending the ritual, he did not go mad and kept about his daily routine including meeting up with Foster on occasion. Thus she never went to the manor and did not lose her eye and arm.

However, the big issue for me is: Foster comes to Dunwall looking for Emily/Corvo to help her rescue Sokolov. The reason she never rescued him herself was that she was injured (missing eye and arm) and knew she would not be capable of infiltrating the Addermire Institute because of these injuries.... which she no longer has.

And this ladies and gentlemen is why timey-whimey storytelling is my least favorite genre - it's poorly planned, even more poorly executed and just plain lazy. No wonder I am unimpressed with the novels which are rife with it - ugh.