Talk:Old Diary (Death of the Outsider)/@comment-1500935-20170924172954/@comment-16533050-20170924190320

Regardless, there is no confirmation, unless I am missing something, that this is Emily's diary.

The facts are thus:
 * The diary is dated 1841
 * The phrasing of the third paragraph alludes to the writer's mother being departed in or before 1841
 * The writer was in the Estates District in or before 1841
 * The writer's father had to save the writer from a pond in the Estate District in or before 1841
 * The writer knows Anton, presumably meaning Anton Sokolov
 * The writer has some amateur knowledge of the workings of silvergraphs and audiographs

That's it. While Emily DOES qualify for the majority of these facts, these same facts by no means disqualify any number of other people with similar experiences.

Obviously, if the diary page is kept in Emily's box, then yes. However, the page does not confirm that. Is there a master list indicating the owners of which box is which?