Talk:Billie Lurk/@comment-8944282-20161026004725/@comment-3242762-20161120111546

Ox and I were talking  about this the other day.

The panel in the comic is angled to excentuate the knife. And I, too, believe it's the same knife.

BUT...

Zhukov finds the knife in Utyka Prison between 1848-1849. Billie is seen with it in 1849 at the end of the comic book. Zhukov still has it in 1851 until it disappears. One: I can't see Billie planting it in Utyka prison. And two: If Zhukov had it first there's no way he'd let Billie borrow it, so what's going on?

So, this unfortunately may cast a shadow of doubt over that theory. (There may be more clues in game but I haven't completed it yet).